A Stock Market Fable
In fact, in 2007, just before the market's peak, I wrote a newspaper column with this amusing story: One day, a man appeared in a village and offered to buy all the monkeys that the villagers could supply for Rs 1,000 each. The villagers caught all the monkeys around and sold them. Soon, another man appeared and offered Rs 2,000 for each monkey. However, there weren't any more monkeys around so that the villagers couldn't sell the man anything. However, they figured that, for some reason, the demand for monkeys was going up, so they looked for the first man and bought back all the monkeys for Rs 3,000 each (which was the least the man was willing to take). Unfortunately, this stratagem failed, and the buyer never reappeared, leaving the villagers stuck with the animals.
Nearby, there was another village where the same story was repeated, except it was about goats. The final buyer also never appeared, and the villagers were stuck with the goats. However, there was a big difference. The monkeys were a nuisance. They were noisy, troublesome, and dangerous, and they stole food all the time, so the villagers eventually abandoned them in the forest. The goats, however, were alright. They were easy to keep, grazed on grass and gave milk. When they grew older, the villagers slaughtered them for meat. All in all, buying goats was not the bad deal it looked like initially.
For investors in today’s raging bull market, the moral of the story should be obvious. In this heated market, take great care to differentiate between the 'monkeys' and the 'goats' in your portfolio. The 'monkeys' are the speculative stocks, hyped up by market sentiment but lacking fundamental value. When the market inevitably corrects, these stocks may prove to be not just worthless but actively detrimental to your financial health. The 'goats', on the other hand, represent companies with solid fundamentals, strong business models, and the ability to generate real value over time.
The goats are expensive, too, but at least they will deliver value even after buyers disappear
Do you remember the atmosphere in the equity markets towards the end of 2007? The Sensex had been up about five times over the previous five years, and really, there was a madness in the air. There seemed to be no end to how high and how fast stocks could rise. We all remember how it ended, but that’s not my point today. My point is not what happened to the markets when they crashed but to individual companies when they recovered.
Whenever the markets rise like they did then, they eventually crash. It was inevitable then, and it’s inevitable now. There may be some doubt about when it will happen and by how much, but it will definitely happen. To a seasoned equity investor, this is nothing unexpected. Ups and downs are part of the game.
The part that few investors appreciate is that these are dangerous times. Over the next few years, when the dust settles in the next market cycle, you will find that these weren’t great times as far as buying stocks was concerned. You might think I’m saying this only because during bull runs, valuations are high, and stocks are expensive. You would be right, but that’s not the only reason and the biggest one. The biggest reason is psychological. When anything you buy makes money, the constant skepticism that investors need disappears from their brains.
This euphoria can lead to poor decision-making, where investors ignore fundamental analysis and chase momentum. They may overlook company financial or governance red flags, blinded by the allure of quick gains. Moreover, even mediocre companies can see their stock prices soar during these times, creating a false sense of security. It's crucial to remember that when the tide eventually turns, the quality of the underlying business will determine which stocks survive and thrive, not just market sentiment
Credit Dhirendra Kumar
I hope you found this note useful and interesting. What did you think of today’s note? Let me know.
If you know anyone who would enjoy it, please forward this email. They can sign up for free here.
You can also subscribe to the Hindi version here.
Was this email forwarded to you?
1 comment:
There is a saying in the Share Markets ,' Sell When they Yell ' - ie SELL -when Buyers are desperate for Buying
Post a Comment